Wondering what your car is really worth in today's Australian market? Skip the guesswork with our practical, data-driven formula that gives you four key pricing points: retail, private sale, trade-in, and wholesale values. Using real-time data from Carsales.com.au, this guide walks you through a step-by-step process to accurately value your vehicle based on current market conditions. Learn how to calculate actual selling prices, understand dealer margins, and determine the best selling strategy for your car. Perfect for anyone looking to sell their vehicle in Australia's dynamic automotive market.
The Simple Answer First
Below is a simple equation that you can use to work out the approximate value of any car on the market at any time. This is not an absolute figure but should put you in the right ballpark:
The Setup
Go to carsales.com.au buy car section, and put in your vehicle's details, make, model, badge and search nationwide etc. Make sure everything is accurate, but for the year put in the surrounding years, so if you're 2020, include 2019 - 2021. Kilometers, you can leave blank. Now sort them from cheapest to most expensive, filter out private sellers and be careful of paid ads, this will give you pure comparable retail figures. You want to compare cars within 30,000 kms either side of yours for accurate data.
Steps:
Go to https://www.carsales.com.au/cars/ buy section Input all your car details. Put a year either side of yours (2019 - 20 - 2021) and leave kilometers blank Use the "sort" feature to sort Cheapest first Use the filters to remove paid ads and private sellers Make sure you are looking nationwide not just in your own state Go down the list and pick out similar cars to yours within 30,000 kms
This will give us an accurate retail asking price.
The Calculation
Deduct from advertised price $2,000 - $3,000 and this will give you the actual selling price after negotiations and on roads Privately, you can get between $1,000 and $2,000 less than dealers (no one will pay you the same price they can buy it from a dealer for) Trade price usually $2,000 - $4,000 less than the actual selling price Wholesale usually $2,000 - $6,000 less than the actual selling price
How It Should Look
Advertised price = $50,000 Actual selling price = $47,000 - $48,000 ($50,000 - $2,000 or $3,000) Private price = $45,000 - $46,000 ($47,000 - $1,000 or $2,000) Trade price = $43,000 - $45,000 ($47,000 - $2,000 or $4,000) Wholesale price = $42,000 - $45,000 ($47,000 - $2,000 or $6,000)
Things to note
This calculation is a good baseline but several factors play a part. More expensive cars (over $70,000) often need larger margins, as do rare cars. Cars with bad selling performance (jeep grand cherokee) or poor reputations (holden cruze) also may not work out as exected. its worth reading the rest of the article to get a full understanding of what does and does not affect your cars value.
Why Car Valuation Is So Complicated
How much is my car worth? The question everyone wants to know the answer but very rarely get reliable results. It sounds like such a simple question but with an expensive asset where the main trend for value is depreciation price becomes subjective. Having worked in the automotive industry for over 7 years mainly in wholesale and bulk fleet purchasing, I have seen first hand how opinions of cars chop and change from dealer to dealer, buyer to buyer.
A prime example of this: if the dealer you approach had trouble selling a car similar to yours recently then they will be put off and lower your price, however if they just sold one with a big lick or within a few days of selling they will usually give you an offer you cannot refuse! On one side you have the godfather and the other you have a little baby who kicks up a stink if things are a little less than easy. This is the "professionals", wait till you try and sell privately! Other than right place, right time, private market is a massive drain on time, resources and mental state especially if you pick a time of year not in line with buy and sell trends or any economic upset (trade wars, high interest rate…)
The fundamental problem with this question is that it does not have one set price across the entire space and can even vary by 10s of thousands for more expensive cars.
The Psychology Behind Pricing Mistakes
Negotiation Room Reality
Even if you sell your car privately you will have to be negotiable, we are living in the age of "best deal" or "discount = value for money" meaning most buyers will walk away (even if it is a good deal) if you don't negotiate even a little bit on price. So look at prices online, and take off a grand and there is the value right? Wrong! I can't tell you how many times I've heard "Well I've got it online for $36,990 so I was hoping to get about 30k after negotiations". There is a completely natural thought process especially from people who have sold a few cars privately to massively overprice their car online to account for the first round of ridiculous offers usually in the vicinity of 5 - 10k off your asking. I remember receiving an offer of $20,000 and an old Holden Cruze for my car listed at $32,990.
The "I've Seen These Selling For" Trap
"I've seen these selling for $39,990", this is the number one reason people can't sell their car privately. There is an assumption that cleaning your car regularly, having it serviced by the dealer and being a one old lady owner who only drives up and down the road increase the value of your car, and there is some merit to this but more so in saleability not overall value.
Here is an example: Margaret with the above car lists for $35,990. Now David who is just as scrupulous with his car looks online and says "well if this one is 36k then mine is definitely worth more as his will definitely be in better condition so he lists for $38,990. And so it goes until they have been online for 6 months and wonder why they have not sold. Meanwhile Steve who is just a bloke who looks after his car well but nothing out of the ordinary looks online and thinks "okay, majority of these are listed for 32k - 35k, I want to sell it quickly so I will ask for 34k but will sell for 32k if the offer comes along" boom, 1 month later his is gone but Margaret and Dave can't stomach the thought of selling for 4 and 7k less than their listing price so they stay online and the cars on the market drop but they stay strong (and not selling).
You might think they will eventually change their mind right? Wrong! I once saw a bloke who was listing his Honda Accord, he had been trying to sell it for well over 1500 days (over 4 years!) Every couple of months he would change a few photos or upload videos of it freshly polished etc.
Dealership listings are for profit prices and usually higher because with buying from a business you have more assurances if something goes wrong, not to mention warranty, ease of sale etc, so for a private owner selling their car, not an ideal comparison either.
Your Selling Options and What They Mean for Price
Important Questions to Consider First
Before asking "How much is my car worth?" consider: How quickly do you want to sell? How much effort are you willing to put in? How much would you like to get for your car? (just a ballpark) Are you flexible on any of these?
Both speed and effort will dictate the value left in your car. If you are willing to put in all the time and effort, you don't care how long it takes you just want the max value, then you will have to join Margaret and Dave. An unwavering desire to get back the absolute maximum value it could ever be worth is admirable but with a depreciating asset such as this, it bears little fruit.
If you want to sell it quickly, list competitively. If you want a quick sale and little to no effort then you're in the dealers ballpark now. So straight away, with 2 more questions added, you can remove options which will help you hone in on your car's value.
Trade Price (Dealers)
For buyers that want to sell your car after we will call this trade price, not to be confused with trade-in price which comes with selling and buying (we will touch on that later). Trade price varies from dealer to dealer, it depends on the dealer's overheads, size, locations, personal opinion, what the weather is doing and what star sign you are. There is not "one size fits all" for pricing. Usually you will find most buyers within a 3 grand window of difference with some outliers (usually on the negative side) but most will be in this vicinity of each other and usually within 3 - 5k of retail listing price (the cost of doing business).
These offers are fast but the only caveat is they will be onsite offers meaning you will physically drive your car in. Not a big deal I hear you say and it's not but don't think for a second that dealer will give you the best price without a fight, and remember how I said some were like babies earlier? If you go in too high on your first price or too firm then they would rather let you walk than give you the best price… Also how are you going to figure out the true value if you don't compare, so now you've been to 2 dealers and gotten a good real offer, right? Wrong! My own personal research shows that you have to go to at least 6 dealers to gather enough information to make an informed decision, that could take you a whole day and if you get a bad run of dealers then you still might be coming up short.
Wholesale Option
The alternative to this is wholesalers, minimal effort, they will do it all. Come to your house, pick up your car, pay you upfront, sounds too good to be true, right? Right! This comes with the catch that they are looking to resell to a dealer now in most cases this means you would get 1 - 2k less than what a dealer puts on it but it's kind of 50/50 which way it goes. As I mentioned, where there is subjectivity on price nothing is straight forward.
Taking your car to a wholesaler is simple (just an online inquiry) and it's like driving your car to 10 - 30 dealers nationwide, you only deal with one person, negotiate one time on the phone and then usually again to a lower extent in person with home visit inspection. Paid first and collected. The price you get can sometimes be more than what the dealers offer for a much more convenient service.
This price is usually 5 - 7k lower than the retail asking (the cost of doing business to business). The downside here comes from that if you make an inquiry on one, you will likely do a few others as well which makes sense but just prepare to be bombarded with calls, texts, emails… If you do inquire, they automatically assume they are buying your car and will act as such. If you get them out to do the assessment and aren't happy with the final price, you better have a strong resolve for what comes next.
What Now?
Now you should be fully equipped to navigate the open market and make the most of your sale without leaving money on the table, but, what if I told you there is an easier way. By now and by the tone of this article, you may be thinking that I am outside the normal range of most people in the industry and might have a bit of a chip on my shoulder about the current process, and you would be right!
For years, I have thought to myself, it doesn't need to be this hard, people want to sell and people want to buy and that's all there is to it, so how come, in an industry so aligned between the business and the customer is there so much conflict and animosity. It mainly comes down to pride, sellers don't want to compromise more than they set out to and buyers don't want to give in and work to get a deal done. Well we here at motorly.com.au are looking to remove all the emotion from the process with logic, facts and science!
We have created an automated process that allows you to explore every option on the market without lifting a finger. Simply tell us about your car, the things that matter most to you and we will use our state of the art AI system to not only tell you what is possible for you and how you can sell your car we will go a step further and put you right at the end of the process with just final offers verified buyers that are looking to buy your car!
Get started now